The Erudition of Sherlock Holmes by Giles Chanot

The Erudition of Sherlock Holmes by Giles ChanotThe Erudition of Sherlock Holmes by Giles Chanot
Published by Truncated Tales Limited on 4/1/2017
Genres: Mystery
Format: Ebook
Source: NetGalley
Goodreads
two-stars

The Erudition of Sherlock Holmes is a new novella set in the late 19th Century, and is some sort of mystery detective thing involving a lot of Holmes’ mystical handwaving and mansplanations of things. There are a few subplots, mostly involved around some sort of running gag about whiskey, which I won’t spoil, didn’t seem to be going anywhere for most of this book.

According the Dictionary.com, erudition is defined as “knowledge acquired by study, research, etc.; learning; scholarship.”

I felt this was relevant to the review because as I was reading this book I felt constantly in the dark as just what the hell was actually going on in the book. The story is told from John Watson’s point of view, as he traipses around various poorly-described parts of Europe (apart from when they climbed a mountain, which was juicily described).

I am a fan of the Sherlock Holmes universe, and enjoy new takes on the old characters, from the BBC Sherlock series to the Johnny Lee Miller vehicle Elementary, but this just felt dull. Perhaps it was the deliberately old style writing, but the pacing really dragged, and despite its relatively short length, took an inordinately long time for me to finish.

This may appeal to a more traditional Sherlock enthusiast, who is happy to wade through tedious archaic language for the traditional ‘genius explains everything at the end’ finish, but this did absolutely nothing for me.

I received a review copy through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

two-stars
Rating Report
Plot
two-stars
Characters
three-stars
Writing
one-half-stars
Pacing
two-stars
Cover
one-half-stars
Overall: two-stars

Similar Posts
The Fallen Gatekeepers by C R Fladmark
The Fallen Gatekeepers seems like a relatively standard portal fantasy, with people from Earth with special powers being able to travel...
China Strike by Matt Rees
Thank god for the synopsis provided by the publisher, because I really had no idea what was going on in...
Star Wars: Catalyst (a Rogue One novel) by James Luceno
Star Wars: Catalyst (a Rogue One novel) by James Luceno
With the upcoming release of the Rogue One movie, I was quite excited to see the release of this prequel...

There are no comments yet, add one below.

Leave a Reply


Name (required)

Email (required)

Website